Sydney, Australia -
Newsfile Corp. - July 30, 2026 - Vantage Goldfields Limited (
Vantage Goldfields) owns Vantage Goldfields Pty Ltd (
VGL), Barbrook Mines Pty Ltd (
Barbrook) and Makonjwaan Imperial Mining Company (Pty) Ltd (
MIMCO) (collectively the
Vantage Companies), which own the Barbrook and Lily mines in
South Africa. The Vantage Companies are currently in business rescue in
South Africa, which is the legal process that assists financially
distressed companies restructure, or otherwise avoid liquidation.
Both AIM listed Metals One Plc (
Metals One) and TSX-V listed Lions Bay Capital Inc. (
Lions Bay)
made announcements on 30 June 2026 about a purported transaction by
their controlled entities Lions Bay Resources Pty Ltd and Lions Bay
Mining Pty Ltd (together
LBR) involving Barbrook (
Announcements) which Vantage
Goldfields believes are misleading and fail to disclose material
information. Those Announcements referred to the dismissal of litigation
involving Barbrook, the purported implementation of LBR's proposal to
acquire the assets of Barbrook and a proposed reverse takeover
transaction involving Lions Bay acquiring LBR, and which would result in
Metals One becoming a major shareholder of Lions Bay.
Both Metals One and Lions Bay in their Announcements have conceded
that "There can be no assurance that the Proposed Transaction will be
completed as proposed or at all".
Vantage Goldfields believes the Announcements are misleading and fail to
disclose relevant material information regarding the Vantage Companies
and LBR proposal for the reasons and given the matters set out below,
including because:
- - There is ongoing litigation in relation to LBR and Barbrook that
will prevent LBR from implementing or completing any acquisition of
assets of Barbrook.
- - LBR has not concluded or substantially implemented any
transaction involving Barbrook and does not own or have title to any
Barbrook assets or have any security over those assets.
- - LBR has not obtained section 11 consent and does not satisfy the statutory requirements under the
Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development - Act ( MPRDA) to obtain section 11 consent, and so will not be able to implement or complete any acquisition of Barbrook's assets.
- - LBR, Metals One and Lions Bay do not have all the funds necessary
to acquire the assets of Barbrook and reopen and operate the Barbrook
mine, and are now trying to implement a convoluted, complicated, highly
conditional reverse takeover scheme to try to desperately raise funds,
which will never succeed.
- - There are alternative credible, viable and funded offers to
provide at least US$50 million to pay creditors of all three Vantage
Companies that would result in the rescue of all those companies and the
reopening of both the Barbrook and Lily mines, that are far superior to
the unfunded LBR proposal, and that are ready to be implemented.
These matters are being brought to the attention of Metals One's
nominated adviser, the AIM and TSX regulatory teams, and corporate
regulators in England and Canada. Any potential funders, investors,
partners or parties contracting with LBR, Metals One or Lions Bay should
be aware of and carefully consider these matters as they could have a
material adverse effect on them.
Those important key matters include:
There is ongoing litigation in relation to LBR and Barbrook that
will prevent LBR from implementing or completing any acquisition of
assets of Barbrook.
Metals One falsely claimed on 30 June that there was no outstanding
litigation in relation to Barbrook and that all legal challenges had
been defeated. This is not true. The only matter decided by the court at
that time was regarding a procedural matter requiring affected persons
to be served and joined to the proceedings. The application to set aside
the purported plan and LBR's proposal for Barbrook had been recommenced
by the time that Metals One made its Announcement, and the court has
granted orders resolving the procedural issue so the litigation will be
proceeding.
Furthermore, other key proceedings involving Barbrook and LBR were never
dismissed and will also be proceeding, including an application to
remove Mr Devereux as a business rescue practitioner of the Vantage
Companies due to his unlawful acts, failure to comply with his duties
and the South African Companies Act and not acting in the best interests
of all creditors and affected persons; and the formal recognition of
the appointment of a second business rescue practitioner by Vantage
Goldfields as confirmed by the Companies and Intellectual Property
Commission (CIPC), the corporate regulator in South Africa.
The application to set aside the purported plan and LBR's proposal for
Barbrook is based on numerous grounds including the failure to comply
with requirements of the Companies Act, including by Mr Devereux,
repeated misrepresentations regarding funding available to LBR, and
unlawful acts in purporting to adopt and implement LBRs proposal in
relation to Barbrook. Vantage Goldfields believes this set aside
application will be granted and the court will overturn and terminate
the LBR transaction and unwind any steps taken by LBR, including because
LBR does not own any assets of Barbrook and is only an unsecured
creditor and can be dealt with as such.
Metals One in a previous announcement made on 17 April 2026 accepted
that the outcome of any current or future proceedings is inherently
uncertain, and any material adverse outcome could have a material
adverse effect upon LBR's financial performance and results of
operations. Consequently, it would also have a material adverse effect
on Metals One and Lions Bay, given that LBR represents the vast majority
of their assets, and potentially on any parties dealing with them in
relation to the Barbrook transaction or any of Barbrook's assets
.
LBR has not concluded or substantially implemented any transaction
involving Barbrook and does not own or have title to any Barbrook assets
or have any security over those assets.
LBR's acquisition of any assets of Barbrook is entirely conditional upon
LBR obtaining consent under section 11 of the MPRDA , which has not
been obtained and may never be obtained. Therefore, LBR has not
concluded or substantially implemented any transaction involving
Barbrook.
Furthermore, the Companies Act prohibits the disposal of any assets
without the prior consent of secured creditors. The largest secured
creditors of Barbrook have informed Vantage Goldfields that they have
not and will not consent to the disposal of any assets of Barbrook to
LBR. Nor have they or will they consent to the granting of any security
over any Barbrook assets to LBR or any other person. Additionally, the
processing plant, surface gold and tailings materials are jointly owned
by MIMCO, and MIMCO has not agreed to transfer any jointly owned assets
to LBR, nor will the secured creditors allow this to occur.
Accordingly, LBR has not acquired and does not own or have title to any
assets of Barbrook and is not entitled to deal with such assets, nor
does it have any security over any such assets. To date, due to its lack
of funding, LBR has only taken limited steps towards implementation by
paying some employees and a limited number of creditors, largely being
affiliated with LBR, including one of its other shareholders Salamander
Pty Ltd (
Salamander) which manages and runs LBR. To the extent
that LBR has made any such payments it is only an unsecured creditor of
Barbrook, ranking behind any secured and preferred creditors, and
consequently at risk in relation to any such unsecured claims. Any
potential funders, investors, partners or parties contracting with LBR
in relation to any Barbrook assets would similarly be at risk.
While Metals One claims that LBR's unaudited accounts show it has assets
of US$12.1 million (and liabilities of US$10.3 million), it fails to
disclose that those assets do not comprise any asset of Barbrook, and
are no more than unsecured creditor claims. This presents significant
risks for Metals One and Lions Bay and their shareholders and creditors,
given that LBR represents the vast majority of their assets.
LBR has not obtained section 11 consent, and does not satisfy the
statutory requirements under the MPRDA to obtain section 11 consent ,
and so will not be able to implement or complete any acquisition of
Barbrook's assets.
LBR's acquisition of any assets of Barbrook is entirely conditional upon
LBR obtaining consent under section 11 of the MPRDA, which has not been
obtained. Furthermore, as LBR cannot satisfy the statutory requirements
to be able to obtain such consent then it may never be obtained, so
that LBR will not be able to implement or complete any acquisition of
Barbrook's assets.
Section 11 consent cannot be granted unless LBR can meet all statutory
requirements under the MPRDA that include proving it has the financial
resources to reopen and optimally operate the Barbrook mines, that it
has the technical ability to conduct the mining operation and is capable
of carrying out and complying with all obligations under the MPRDA. LBR
fails to satisfy these requirements.
LBR has repeatedly failed to provide any verifiable proof that it has
all the funds required to fully pay all creditors, requiring at least an
additional US$7 million, or the further US$30 million that LBR has
publicly conceded will be required to reopen and operate the Barbrook
mine. Nor can Metals One or Lions Bay provide such funding, and they
have both conceded in previous stock exchange announcements that they do
not have and have not secured such funding, and have received no more
than a non-binding indicative proposal for some funding.
LBR, Metals One and Lions Bay have never opened or operated a mine and
do not have the experience or capability to do so. To the contrary, LBR
is managed and run by one of its shareholders Salamander, which has a
track record of failure in relation to the Barbrook mine. Salamander
entered into a joint venture in 2018 in relation to processing of the
Barbrook tailings, but failed to perform its contractual obligations,
which caused the failure of the original business rescue plans for the
Vantage Companies which relied heavily on the cashflow that should have
been generated by those tailings. Given Salamander's track record of
failure in relation to the Barbrook tailings, and that it runs and
manages LBR, there is no credibility in any claim by LBR that it can
reopen and operate the Barbrook mine. Therefore, LBR does not have the
expertise or the technical ability to successfully reopen or operate the
Barbrook mine or to meet obligations in terms of the MPRDA in respect
of the mine, so that the statutory requirements to obtain sections 11
consent would not be satisfied.
Furthermore, Vantage Goldfields has had discussions with the Department of Mineral and Petroleum Resources (
DMPR)
which confirmed that, consistent with their approach previously, they
want both the Barbrook and Lily mines reopened and operating,
recognising that Barbrook, MIMCO and their mines are operationally,
functionally and legally interdependent , so that they will not grant a
section 11 consent for Barbrook alone.
LBR, Metals One and Lions Bay do not have all the funds necessary
to acquire the assets of Barbrook and reopen and operate the Barbrook
mine, and are now trying to implement a convoluted, complicated, highly
conditional reverse takeover scheme to try to desperately raise funds,
which will never succeed.
Metals One and Lions Bay have used almost all of their cash resources to
fund LBR. Metals One in its Announcement referred to LBR being provided
with R161 million (about US$10 million) and LBR having paid R151
million to employees and creditors, leaving LBR with no more than R10
million (less than US$600,000). This is manifestly significantly less
than would be required to pay all creditors of Barbrook, at least US$7
million, or the additional US$30 million required to reopen and operate
the Barbrook mine, so that at least a further US$37 million is required.
Both Metals One and Lions Bay have conceded in previous stock exchange
announcements that they do not have and have not secured the funds
required and have received no more than a non-binding indicative
proposal for some funding.
So LBR, Metals One and Lions Bay have run out of funds and have not been
able to secure all the necessary funding to even pay all creditors, let
alone the significant funding required to reopen and operate the
Barbrook mine.
Consequently, they have concocted a convoluted, complicated, highly
conditional reverse takeover scheme in a desperate attempt to try to
raise funds, which is destined to fail, including because:
- - a key condition is obtaining section 11 consent, which cannot be obtained for the reasons set out above;
- - there are significant further conditions including approval of TSX,
AIM, preparation and registration of a prospectus/registration statement
and admission document and approval by SEC, shareholders and other
third parties. These approvals will be impossible to obtain while there
is ongoing litigation and where LBR does not own any Barbrook assets and
cannot provide any security over those assets; nor would it be possible
to raise funds in those circumstances.
- - such a convoluted, complicated, highly conditional scheme would take
at least a year to implement but will never succeed in any event.
There are alternative credible, viable and funded offers to
provide at least US$50 million to pay creditors of all three Vantage
Companies that would result in the rescue of all those companies and the
reopening of both the Barbrook and Lily mines, that are far superior to
the unfunded LBR proposal, that are ready to be implemented.
The joint business rescue practitioners and Vantage Goldfields have
received several alternative credible, viable and funded proposals that
would result in the rescue of all three Vantage companies and the
reopening of both the Lily and Barbrook mines, including proposals from
offerors with real experience in mining operations for the rescue of all
three Vantage Companies for at least
USD 65 million and
USD 85 million, both providing at least an initial
USD 50 million for payments to creditors and the reopening of the
mines, supported by institutional funders. These offers are ready to be
implemented, including when the court sets aside the purported Barbrook
plan and LBR proposal.
All these offers are far superior to the unfunded LBR proposal which Mr
Devereux is pursuing, but he has refused to engage with those offerors.
This reflects Mr Devereux's conflict of interest and failure to act in
the best interests of all creditors and affected persons, which seems to
be based on the fact that he will be paid R40 million ( about US$2.5
million) if he pushes through the LBR proposal.
Vantage Goldfields intends to ensure that all viable proposals are
properly considered for the business rescue of the Vantage Companies,
and that the business rescue process is progressed and implemented
properly in accordance with South African law. Vantage Goldfields
remains fully committed to reopening the Lily and Barbrook mines for the
benefit of all creditors, former employees, affected persons and other
stakeholders of the Vantage Companies.
Stephen Turner
Chairman-Vantage Goldfields
st@stephenturner.com.au
This press release contains forward-looking statements, including
statements about our future operations, plans, objectives, expectations,
estimates, forecasts, or projections. Forward-looking statements are
inherently subject to known and unknown risks, uncertainties,
assumptions, and other factors that may cause actual results,
performance, or outcomes to differ materially from those expressed or
implied.
Vantage Goldfields believes the forward-looking statements in this
release are based on reasonable grounds; however, events or
circumstances may cause actual results to differ.
These risks and uncertainties may include, among other things, changes
in market conditions, economic factors, industry developments,
operational challenges, regulatory changes, and other factors known or
unknown to the company.
Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date of this release,
and except as required by law, the company undertakes no obligation to
update or revise any forward-looking statements to reflect new
information, future events, or changed circumstances.
Source:
Vantage Goldfields Limited